I’d rather entrust the government of the United States to the first 400 people listed in the Boston telephone directory than to the faculty of Harvard University.
William F. Buckley, Jr.
One of my daily political blog reads is Ace of Spades. I find myself agreeing with Ace much of the time. However, a couple of days ago, I ran across a post that Ace did about Sarah Palin and her supposed lack of ‘gravitas’ on things more intellectual.
This passage in particular bothered me:
A lot of Palin’s supporters blow this off and essentially offer an anti-intellect defense: Well that stuff doesn’t matter anyway.
Well, for some of us it does. And if Palin could put these questions to rest, but doesn’t, she’s alienating a lot of potential supporters. Some of us can’t just tell ourselves, “I don’t care about what’s in her head, I care about what’s in her heart” or some pablum like that.
So you tell me if it matters. I think it does. 90% of the Palin critics, skeptics, and now outright opponents find little fault with her policy portfolio, or her bio, or her cultural background, or her charisma. (Obviously on the latter.)
For 90% of us it’s this one thing.
So you tell me it doesn’t matter.
I don’t have to tell you it doesn’t matter, history will tell you that what matters. Looking at history, what matters most is core beliefs, principles and adherence to the ideals of limited government.
Take a look at Woodrow Wilson. In the late 1800′s they didn’t grant Ph.D’s like they do today. So, the fact that Woodrow Wilson earned a Ph.D. in history and political science in 1886, is quite an academic accomplishment. No one would doubt his intellect.
What did Wilson accomplish with his superior intellect during time in office? He created the League of Nations (the forerunner to the UN), the Federal Reserve and got us involved in WWI. He also backed a slew of legislation that put new controls on big business and supported unions. The repercussions of Woodrow Wilson’s superior intellect are still being felt today (and not in a good way).
Would any conservative vote for Woodrow Wilson today? He certainly had a lot going on in his head.
Looking at the other side of the coin, would conservatives support someone like Calvin Coolidge who had a solid conservative ideology:
Coolidge’s nickname was “Silent Cal.” He was known for his silence. He believed that the government should have as small a role as possible in the country. He believed that the country’s well-being was best preserved by allowing business to create wealth. His most famous remark was in a speech that he made in 1925 in which he stated: “The business of America is business.”
Wilson had Ph.D. from Princeton University and Coolidge graduated from Amherst College. I think its safe to say, Wilson was ‘smarter’ (in a strictly academic sense) than Calvin Coolidge. However, like most conservatives I would vote for Coolidge every time.
Looking at recent history, Ronald Reagan, who graduated from Eureka College, endured continuous mocking as not being too bright. However, he possessed a strong , conservative world view and ended up a fantastic President.
History demonstrates that it is more important that a President have a conservative world view rather than being perceived as an intellectual (i.e the what is in their heart pabulum Ace spoke of).
Since Reagan left office, we have been subjected to an unbroken string of Ivy League elites setting the tone for our nation. Look at this list: George H.W. Bush (Yale), the skirt chasing Bill Clinton (Georgetown, Oxford – Rhodes Scholar and Yale), George W. Bush (Yale and Harvard Business – MBA) and Obama (Occidental College, Columbia and Harvard Law School), all Ivy League intellects. With all this supposed intelligence and education at the top, is our nation better off? Do we have less government encroaching in our daily lives and work? Is our economy stronger?
The skirt chasing Rhodes Scholar gave us the housing bubble that helped crash our economy.
George Washington had a surveyor’s certificate from William & Mary College.*
*I know this is not the perfect example, since we know from Washington’s writings he was very intelligent. However, he is remembered and revered because of what was in his heart.